Q. (from slip) Assalamu Alaikum Br. Zakir. As Muslims, we believe that Allah Subhana Wa Taala is ‘Noor’- We cannot attribute any form or gender to Him. Why then, when we speak of Almighty God, or as written in the Holy Qur’an – Allah is always refered to as… ‘ He’?

A. (Dr Zakir): The sister has asked a very good question and this question has troubled me for several years. And she asked the question – Allah is Noor, He has got no form, no gender  – So why  is it written as ‘Hua’… as ‘He’. And this question, I asked to various people… you know in India and other scholars – but  never got a satisfactory reply. Then I myself did a little research and  then I checked it up with the experts. That’s  when I learned Arabic – The grammar… The Arabic grammar has got only two genders – Male and Female. English language, three genders – Male, Female, Neutar. So if you translate ‘Hua’ into English, it can translated as ‘he’ or as ‘it’ –  Either ‘he’ or  ‘it’ Same as ‘Heya’ -If you translate into English, it can be translated as ‘She’ or  ‘It’. That’s Arabic language… – two genders – English language …  3 genders. So ‘Hua’ if you translate, you can translate as  ‘He’ or ‘it. ‘Heya’ as ‘She’ or ‘it’. So ‘Hua’ in English, if you say – Allah Subhana Wa Taala is beyond any gender – So why have they used ‘He’. Some people may say that if ‘Hua’ means ‘He’ and ‘It’, and ‘Heya’ means ‘She’ and ‘It’ – both mean ‘It’.  So why did Allah use ‘Hua’ and not ‘Heya’. Because Qur’an says …(Arabic)…‘Say He is Allah one and only’. When I learned in grammar… in Arabic grammer, I was told, that in the Arabic grammar, there are certain rules and criterias for feminine gender… feminine gender, 1st, if it is feminine in nature like ‘mother’… ‘Ummun’, it becomes a feminine gender. 2nd rule – if it ends with ‘Toh’. ‘Toh’, – it is feminine gender… like Mirvahatun –fan ending  with ‘toh’ it becomes feminine gender. Allah Subhana Wa Taala is not a female… So it can’t be feminine – It is not ending with ‘Toh’.  Is it ending with ‘Toh?’ – No! So can’t be feminine. 3rd is – it should end with ‘Bada Alif’… then it becomes feminine. Allah doesn’t end with ‘Bada Alif’… So it can’t become feminine. And another one – if the pairs of the body – ‘twos’ like eyes… einum feminine, ‘Yadun’… hand, feminine.  Allah is …(Arabic)… Say He is Allah One and only. ‘It is not fair… so therefore is defection, in default… since it can’t be used as ‘Heya’… ‘It’, that she ‘It’ – Allah uses ‘Hua’ ‘It’. Otherwise Allah Subuhana Wa Taala has got no gender at all.

One thought on “Q. (from slip) Assalamu Alaikum Br. Zakir. As Muslims, we believe that Allah Subhana Wa Taala is ‘Noor’- We cannot attribute any form or gender to Him. Why then, when we speak of Almighty God, or as written in the Holy Qur’an – Allah is always refered to as… ‘ He’?

  1. It’s evident you’re struggling with grammar b logic to explain why Alla is addressed as male. Mr Naik, hope you realise God is beyond logic. You expect people to accept your presumptions but criticise when the same is in reference to other faiths . Hypocrite 😂
    Grow up brother, if Arabic grammar doesn’t provide for neutral gender it’s ok, if people addressed alla as Him or Her or It , it’s absolutely fine. Addressing any which way didn’t dilute one’s faith which is most important than your own stupid grammar n logic. You can’t dictate to Islamic world or otherwise how to connect to God.

    Call me for an open debate if at all….👍🤓

    Like

Comments will be moderated before appearing... Kindly do not post questions here, this is an un-official website and we cannot answer on behalf of Dr Zakir Naik.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s